Rare Coin Investing
-
January 10, 2012
The Future Looks Even Brighter for Numismatic Rarities
By Blanchard Economic Research Unit
EXPERT INSIGHTS FROM:
Donald W. Doyle, Jr. Chairman and CEO and
David Beahm: Vice President and Director of Marketing and Economic ResearchThe top 30 coins that Blanchard and Company has placed in the past year boast a value of almost $7 million. In contrast, the top 30 coins placed over the same period in 2006-07 — a robust period for rare coins before the 2008 financial crisis — were valued at just over $5.5 million. No longer fooled by paper assets, wealthy investors are looking for alternative investments. And while gold has been a great addition to investment portfolios, ultra-rare coins now offer a better investment opportunity.
The price of gold has increased by 180% since November 2006, and while rare coins have gained too, they have not kept up with gold — so far. This lag means there’s no better time to buy than now, and savvy investors are doing so, diversifying further within the gold market by adding ultra-rare coins to their portfolios.
Here’s the real investment magic of rare coins: Their price gains often lag behind those of gold, and that characteristic takes much of the guesswork out of investing in rare coins — serving as an early warning signal of impending bull markets and producing periodic windfall profits for knowledgeable investors. Rare coins tend to follow gold’s lead and eventually surpass bullion prices. Bull markets in rare coins have always occurred during or after periods of rising gold prices, and reliable, independent reports show that average annual returns on rare coins historically have been more than twice as great as the returns on gold bullion.
When gold soared above $850 in 1980, the prices of rare coins rose more than twice as much — and kept going up after the price of gold fell.
In 1987, when gold started a rally that took it back above $500, rare coins again lagged but then rocketed past gold, with the market for investment-grade rare coins going up several hundred percent even as the price of gold fell from $500 to $360.
As reflected in the following key-dates and rarities chart, rare coins have stabilized and are poised to rise as traditional investments lose their luster.
Look at the number of ultra-rare coins — each worth more than $150,000 — that Blanchard has placed in the past year versus those in 2006-07.. The data suggest that wealthy investors are allocating more of their investment dollars into an asset that has underperformed gold bullion but is poised eventually to outperform gold and other investments.
November 2006 to November 2007 Description Grade $50 PAN-PAC 1915-S OCTAGONAL MS67 $4 STELLA 1879 FLOWING HAIR CAMEO PR66 $4 STELLA 1879 FLOWING HAIR CAMEO PR66 $4 STELLA 1879 FLOWING HAIR PR65 $4 STELLA 1879 FLOWING HAIR CAMEO PR65 $50 PAN-PAC 1915-S ROUND MS66 $20 ST GAUDENS 1907 HIGH RELIEF MS67 $4 STELLA 1879 FLOWING HAIR CAMEO PR64 $4 STELLA 1879 FLOWING HAIR CAMEO PR64 $5 LIBERTY 1795 LARGE MS62 $20 LIBERTY 1898 ULTRA CAMEO PR66 1776 PEWTER DOLLAR 2RS MS64 $4 STELLA 1879 FLOWING HAIR PR63 $20 LIBERTY 1896 DEEP CAMEO PR66 $20 LIBERTY 1894 ULTRA CAMEO PR66 $4 STELLA 1879 FLOWING HAIR CAMEO PR63 $20 ST GAUDENS 1910 PR67 $20 LIBERTY 1886 ULTRA CAMEO PR66 $50 PAN-PAC 1915-S OCTAGONAL MS65 $4 STELLA 1879 FLOWING HAIR PR61 November 2010 to November 2011 Description Grade $4 STELLA 1879 FLOWING HAIR + PR67C $20 LIBERTY 1870-CC XF45 HENTSCH GLD BAR SSCA 3114 N/A $20 ST GAUDENS 1930-S MS65 $20 ST GAUDENS 1930-S MS65C J&H BAR MARYS SSCA #9501 N/A BLAKE GOLD BAR SSCA #5186 N/A $4 STELLA 1879 FLOWING HAIR PR65C $20 LIBERTY 1864 ULTRA CAMEO PR64 $4 STELLA 1879 FLOWING HAIR PR65 J&H GOLD BAR SSCA #4278 N/A 1792 HALF DISME AU58 $5 DRAPE BUST 1797 SMALL 16S AU55C $20 ST GAUDENS 1931 MS66C $4 STELLA 1879 FLOWING HAIR PR64 J&H BAR MARYS SSCA #9435 N/A K&H GOLD BAR SSCA #952 N/A 1794 FLOW HAIR $1 VF25 $20 ST GAUDENS 1911 PR68 $50 PAN-PAC 1915-S ROUND MS65C $10 DRAPE BUST 1803 EXTRA STAR MS64 $20 ST GAUDENS 1930-S MS64C $5 DRAPE BUST 1795 SMALL MS63 $50 PAN-PAC 1915-S OCTAGONAL MS65C MARCHAND GLD BAR SSC#6460 N/A $5 DRAPE BUST 1797 SMALL AU53 $50 PAN-PAC 1915-S OCTAGONAL MS65C $4 STELLA 1879 FLOWING HAIR PR63 $10 1795 DRAPE BUST SMALL MS62 $20 LIBERTY 1896 CAMEO PR66 1793 LIBERTY CAP 1/2 CENT BN MS61C $20 LIBERTY 1885 ULTRA CAMEO PR65C $4 STELLA 1879 FLOWING HAIR PR62 $20 ST GAUDENS 1910 PR67 $20 LIBERTY 1892 ULTRA CAMEO PR65C 1797 DRAPE BUST HALF XF40C Once introduced to the advantages of rare coins, many of Blanchard and Company’s clients have become proficient at reaping big profits from their coins. Much of the new demand for ultra-rare coins is coming from wealthy baby-boomers, 80 million strong and now in their 50s and 60s.
Already the richest generation in history, they are scheduled to inherit about $225 billion each year over the next decade. The immensity of the boomers’ accumulated wealth is making diversification a prominent part of their financial plans. More and more of them have become collectors and are capitalizing on the numismatic expertise they’ve developed to make their coin collections a valuable, profitable part of their portfolio diversification.
Copyright © 2011 Blanchard and Company, Inc.
By Blanchard Economic Research Unit
EXPERT INSIGHTS FROM:
David Beahm: Vice President and Director of Marketing and Economic Research
Gold has gone from an average annual price of $271 per ounce in 2001 to more than $1,700 today. Those of our clients who stayed out of the gold market in 2000 and 2001, at our direction, saved themselves from losses. Those who got back into the market in 2002, as we recommended, have substantially increased their wealth. We were right then; we’re just as confident that we’re right today when we say we can make even more money for our clients who invest in rare coins.
The historical relationship between gold and numismatics takes much of the guesswork out of investing in rare coins. Rare coins follow gold but eventually surpass gold. Bull markets in rare coins always occur during or after periods of rising gold prices. When a bull market in rare coins gets cranked up, it goes up much further and much faster than does the price of gold. The annual average returns on rare coins have historically been more than 250% greater than returns on gold bullion, reliable independent reports show.
Uncertainty in the U.S. stock market is bullish for tangible assets, having brought about a flight to quality as investors move part of their savings into more stable assets that provide portfolios with much-needed protection and excellent investment returns.
The U.S. economic outlook has deteriorated significantly, and there is much talk of another full-blown financial crisis. Today’s economic conditions present an ideal opportunity to realize windfall profits from rare coins. Our goal, our objective as a company, is to make money for our clients. Today, the key to profits is the fact that rare coins follow gold but eventually go up much further than gold. But timing is everything.
Copyright © 2011 Blanchard and Company, Inc.

Portfolio Log-in